A list is not a conclusion
Pros and cons are only meaningful inside a scope. Without one, they are preferences dressed as findings.
Scope
Which product, version, and situation does the list cover? A con for one situation is not a con for another.
Time
When was the list written? A product that changed may have changed its pros and cons too.
Usage situation
Under what conditions was each point observed? A “con” only holds in the situation it came from.
Evidence
What supports each point? A point without evidence is an assertion, not a finding.
?Open item: is any pro or con being read without its scope, time, situation, or evidence?
A worked read
- List: a page lists pros and cons.
- Scope: no product version or situation is stated.
- Result: the list stays an opinion, not a conclusion.
Source-reading example — not a review, testimonial, rating, comparison result, or verification.
Continue your review
Return to the review source guide, and read comparisons with the comparison disclosure guide.